WP Vol.2 cover, Latent Space and Modal
WP Vol.2 Theoretical Report Forthcoming 1 Dec 2026

Latent Space and Modal

Who Asks the Criteria of the Possible in the AGI Era? (A Theoretical Report Based on the M4 Framework) · 잠재 공간과 모달

Author
Juneho Suh / Modality Lab
서준호 / 모달리티 연구소
ORCID 0009-0007-2037-8675
Series
Working Paper Series
Modality Lab
Publication
1 December 2026
Forthcoming
License
© 2026 Modality Lab
All rights reserved

About this Report

When an AI answers “I can't,” is that impossibility a limit of capability, or a condition someone has set?
In the AGI era, when possibility is calculated and handed to us, who asks the criteria of the possible?

This report is a theoretical attempt to reread the moment when generative models calculate possibility in latent space, not as a matter of machine performance, but as a question of the authority to set conditions. Taking as its criterion whether a calculated possibility appears to the interpreting subject as a condition or only as a fact, it identifies the conditions under which the autonomy of the interpreting subject can hold in the AGI era.

  • Defines the autonomy of the interpreting subject not as the ability to refuse calculation, but as a voice over its conditions
  • Builds on Peircean semiotics and the four layers of Mode, Modal, Modality and Medium (M4), placing latent space as a space of conditions at the Modal layer
  • Four diagnostic propositions, with a single scene, the refusal of an AI, as the case that runs through them: the crisis of the interpreting subject's autonomy, the computation of the Modal, the convergence of the space of possibility, and geometrization and reification
  • Four design principles answering the four diagnoses, and a six-item judgment table applicable to any AI system
  • A clear distinction between description grounded in primary sources on technologies in operation today and conditional outlooks on the AGI stage

Questions this report answers

  • When possibility is calculated and handed to us, does the Modal remain a condition the interpreting subject can still question?
  • Once machines enter the place of interpretation, does human approval remain a judgment, or shrink to a confirmation?
  • As the authority to set conditions shifts toward the system, what should the Medium disclose, and what paths of correction should it keep open?

Intended readers

  • Researchers exploring the humanistic and semiotic implications of generative AI
  • Researchers in Peircean semiotics, media theory and science and technology studies (STS)
  • Researchers and practitioners in AI governance, policy and trustworthiness
  • Readers asking where the interpreting subject stands in the AGI era

Keywords

Latent space Modal Modality Medium M4 Peircean semiotics Autonomy of the interpreting subject Quasi-interpretant Computation of possibility AI refusal Judgment table AGI era

Contents

Preface · Introduction: When Possibility Is Calculated
Part I · Present Coordinates
  • §1The concept of latent space
  • §2The calculation of possibility at work today
  • §3The AGI era as a coordinate
Part II · Diagnosis
  • §4Peirce's three modes of being and the Modal
  • §5Diagnosis 1: the crisis of the interpreting subject's autonomy
  • §6Diagnosis 2: the computation of the Modal
  • §7Diagnosis 3: the convergence of the space of possibility
  • §8Diagnosis 4: geometrization and reification
  • §9Summary of Part II: placing the four diagnoses on M4
Part III · Design
  • §10Normative coordinates: the Peircean semiotic axis and the M4 axis
  • §11Principle 1: the autonomy and openness of the interpreting subject
  • §12Principle 2: the irreducibility of the Modal
  • §13Principle 3: the defense of epistemic diversity
  • §14Principle 4: awareness of geometrization and its passage through the Medium
  • §15Summary of Part III: the judgment table
Part IV · Implications
  • §16From Modal to Modality: whose experience?
  • §17A conditional outlook on the AGI stage: self-set conditions and the place of approval
  • §18The share of the Medium: criteria of demarcation and paths of correction
  • §19Position in the series
Conclusion · Returning Calculated Possibility to Condition
Publisher
Modality Lab (모달리티 연구소)
Series
Modality Lab Working Paper Series
Issue
WP Vol.2 · 2026-02
Publication
Forthcoming, 1 December 2026
Language
Korean (with English summary)
URL
https://modalitylab.org/en/wp/2026-02/